When considering a move to the Minneapolis metropolitan area, two suburban standouts often come to mind: Edina and Minnetonka. Both offer distinct lifestyles, unique attractions, and high-quality living experiences. But which one is the perfect fit for you?

Whether you’re a young professional, a family, or someone looking for serenity with easy access to urban amenities, this article will guide you through the pros and cons of Edina vs Minnetonka to help you make an informed decision.

Introduction to Edina and Minnetonka

Edina and Minnetonka are charming cities that appeal to different lifestyles. Located southwest of Minneapolis, Edina is renowned for its picturesque neighborhoods, excellent schools, and vibrant business scene. It offers a mix of suburban tranquility with the convenience of city proximity, making it a popular choice for professionals and families alike.

On the other hand, Minnetonka, situated just west of Minneapolis, is known for its natural beauty, notably its position by the eastern tip of Lake Minnetonka. This western suburb offers more small-town charm with ample opportunities for outdoor recreation, thanks to its extensive parks and lake access. With a population of around 54,000, Minnetonka delivers a peaceful lifestyle while still being close enough to enjoy the amenities of a major city.

Demographics: Age and Population

One key difference between Edina vs Minnetonka lies in their demographics. Edina has a slightly older population, while Minnetonka skews younger by about 2.3 years on average. This younger population in Minnetonka might be attributed to housing affordability, job opportunities, or lifestyle preferences. Both cities boast populations of just over 53,000, ensuring vibrant community atmospheres.

The younger demographic in Minnetonka may lead to a more dynamic, evolving community with a focus on outdoor activities and family-friendly events. In contrast, Edina, with its older population, offers a more established, tranquil community atmosphere, ideal for those seeking stability and luxury living.

Housing Costs and Real Estate

Housing costs are a major factor for most when choosing a place to live, and Edina and Minnetonka have major differences in this regard. Edina is known for its higher housing prices, which are approximately 24.5% more expensive than Minnetonka. This difference can be the deciding factor in where you live, depending on how tight your housing budget is.

Edina features upscale neighborhoods such as Indian Hills and the Edina Country Club District, which are famous for their spacious, luxurious homes and high-end amenities. Meanwhile, Minnetonka offers a variety of housing styles, from charming cottages to lakeside homes, catering to a broad spectrum of buyers. Its proximity to Lake Minnetonka adds a premium for those seeking water views and lakeside living.

If you’re after luxury and are willing to invest more for a prestigious address, Edina may be your best bet. If instead you are looking for affordability without compromising on quality of life, Minnetonka offers a well-balanced mix of comfort, natural beauty, and more reasonable housing prices.

Commute and Transportation

When it comes to commuting, both suburbs offer convenient access to Minneapolis, though there are slight differences in commute times. On average, residents in Minnetonka have a commute time that is 1.9 minutes longer than those in Edina. While this might seem minor, over time, it could add up.

Public transportation options are robust in both cities. Edina is just eight miles away from the Minneapolis-Saint Paul International Airport, making it ideal for frequent travelers. Express bus services also offer quick routes to downtown Minneapolis. Minnetonka has fewer public transportation options but compensates with scenic routes around Lake Minnetonka and easily accessible highways.

If you prefer a scenic drive or rely less on public transportation, Minnetonka could be more appealing.

Attractions and Recreation

Both Edina and Minnetonka offer an array of recreational activities and attractions, though the experiences they provide can differ by quite a bit.

Edina is home to Centennial Lakes Park, where residents can enjoy paddle boating, mini-golf, and ice skating in the winter. The Edina Aquatic Center and Braemar Golf Course are also popular destinations for families. For culture lovers, the Edina Art Center and Edinborough Park provide creative outlets and indoor recreational opportunities.

In contrast, Minnetonka is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts. With its proximity to Lake Minnetonka, activities like boating, fishing, and kayaking are easily accessible. Parks like Libbs Lake Beach Park and Shady Oak Beach are ideal for those who love spending time near the water. Minnetonka’s lush, wooded surroundings also offer fantastic hiking and biking trails, making it a paradise for nature lovers.

Ultimately, if you are looking for a vibrant mix of urban parks, shopping, and cultural experiences, Edina might be more up your alley. If serene natural landscapes and outdoor recreation are your priorities instead, Minnetonka should be on your radar.

Education and Schools

Both cities boast excellent education systems, making them ideal for families with school-aged children. Edina is part of the Edina Public School District, one of the top-ranked districts in Minnesota. It is well-regarded for its rigorous academics and extracurricular activities. Edina High School, in particular, has an outstanding reputation in both academics and athletics.

Minnetonka’s public schools, part of the Minnetonka, Hopkins, and Wayzata school districts, are equally impressive. The Minnetonka School District stands out for its innovative programs and high student success rates. Minnetonka also offers a variety of private and parochial school options so families can choose the best fit for their children.

Whether you prioritize advanced placement programs, extracurricular activities, or innovative learning environments, both Edina and Minnetonka offer exceptional educational opportunities.

Community and Quality of Life

The quality of life in Edina and Minnetonka is a major draw for prospective residents, and both cities deliver on this front in different ways.

Edina is known for its well-maintained neighborhoods, a strong sense of community, and a variety of local attractions. The 50th & France district, a bustling area with restaurants, boutiques, and cultural activities, adds to the city’s appeal. Extensive parks and green spaces further increase the livability of Edina, offering year-round recreational activities.

Minnetonka, with its proximity to Lake Minnetonka, offers a more nature-focused lifestyle. Residents can enjoy boating, fishing, hiking, and biking throughout the year. The city is also home to major employers like UnitedHealth Group, giving residents access to both work and leisure without the need to travel far. Minnetonka’s blend of small-town charm and suburban conveniences makes it an appealing choice for those seeking a quieter lifestyle.

Choosing Between Edina and Minnetonka

In the end, the decision between Edina and Minnetonka comes down to your personal priorities. Edina stands out for its luxurious housing, excellent schools, and vibrant local scene, making it ideal for those who value community engagement and urban conveniences.

Minnetonka, with its more affordable housing, younger population, and abundant outdoor recreation, offers a peaceful retreat for nature lovers and families looking for more space and serenity.

Both suburbs deliver high-quality living experiences with excellent schools, a range of housing options, and close proximity to Minneapolis. The choice between the two depends on whether you lean toward a more luxurious, established community or a nature-focused, dynamic lifestyle.

Plan Your Move Now With Us!

Are you planning a move to Edina or Minnetonka? Let Piepho Moving & Storage make it effortless. With our dedicated team creating a smooth, efficient, and personalized moving experience, you will be settled into your new home in no time.

Whether you are drawn to the bright and busy lifestyle of Edina or the serene beauty of Minnetonka, we are here to handle every step of the process.

Get your free quote today, and let us help you start the next chapter of your journey with ease!